原文传递
Subjectivity versus Objectivity: Comparative Study between Brute Force Method and Genetic Algorithm for Calibrating the SLEUTH Urban Growth Model
| 题名： | Subjectivity versus Objectivity: Comparative Study between Brute Force Method and Genetic Algorithm for Calibrating the SLEUTH Urban Growth Model |
| 其他题名： | Eastman,R.(2009)."Idrisi Taiga Version 16.01."Clark Laboratories,Clark Univ.,Worcester,MA. |
| 正文语种： | 英文 |
| 作者： | Javad Jafarnezhad |
| 关键词： | Brute force;Genetic algorithm;SLEUTH;Model performance;Spatial simulation;Iran |
| 摘要： | Urban growth models (UGM) as regional planning tools are of great interest for quantitative analysis of urban complex systems. As a crucial step, model calibration is one of the most important and challenging steps when trying to simulate a spatial phenomenon. The current paper adopts two different approaches to calibrate a popular geospatial simulation model, the SLEUTH UGM. The conventional Brute Force as a subjective method and the genetic algorithm (GA) as an objective approach were implemented to calibrate the model for three study locations of Azadshahr, Gonbadekavoos, and Gorgan Cities, Golestan Province, Iran. Model simulation success was measured and compared for three modeling efforts using multiple methods [optimized SLEUTH metric (OSM), Kappa coefficient, receiving operator characteristic (ROC) statistic and landscape metrics]. Results indicated that GA-based model calibration out-performed the Brute Force method in terms of landscape metrics, Kappa coefficient (Khisto) and the final OSM values. On the other hand, the Brute Force model yielded better results for Klocation. Both models depicted an approximately equal performance in terms of the ROC statistic. The majority of the resultant growth coefficients derived from both methods were relatively close, while GA-base model calibration out-paced the Brute Force with a noticeable less time-consuming process to calibrate the model. |
| 出版年： | 2016 |
| 论文唯一标识： | P-84Y2016V142N03016 |
| 英文栏目名称： | CASE STUDIES |
| doi： | 10.1061/(ASCE)UP.1943-5444.0000307 |
| 期刊名称： | Journal of Urban Planning and Development |
| 拼音刊名(出版物代码)： | P-84 |
| 卷： | 142 |
| 期： | 03 |
| 页码： | 157-168 |
相关文献
- Predicting Vertical Urban Growth Using Genetic Evolutionary Algorithms in Tokyo's Minato Ward
- New Model for the Lap-Splice Length of Tensile Reinforcement in Concrete Elements
- Process Modeling for Urban Growth Simulation with Cohort Component Method, Cellular Automata Model and GIS/RS: Case Study on Surrounding Area of Seoul, Korea
- Development of Evaluation Model of Urban Growth Stage Considering the Connectivity between Core and Periphery
- Assessing Growth Scenarios for Their Landscape Ecological Security Impact Using the SLEUTH Urban Growth Model
- A Climate-Sensitive Approach for Determining the Urban Growth Boundaries: Towards a Spatial Exploration for Bursa, Turkiye
检索历史
应用推荐
